Get Permission Sehrawat: Amelioration in the sodium hypochlorite as root canal irrigant – A review


Introduction

Endodontic treatment is an amalgamation of the mechanical and chemical prepartation.1 Despite various instrumentation techniques have been introduced in the past, approximately 35% of the root canal surface remained unmarked, which makes it indispensable to employ the disinfecting solutions to irrigate the root canal system. 2 Irrigation kinetics carries out a decisive task in endodontic treatment. 2 The impact of irrigating solution counts upon its mechanism of the action and its capability to affect the microorganisms and dentinal debris within the root canal. 1

A quintessential irrigant should be orally biocompatible, must deliver strong flushing action, be microbiocidal and able to dissolve remnants of organic tissues without being detrimental to the periradicular tissues on extrusion. 1 The classification of root canal irrigants is as follows: 3

Table 1

Endodontic Iirigants

Chemical Agents

Natural Agents

i. Tissue dissolving agents – Sodium hypochlorite, ClO2

i. Green tea

ii. Antibacterial agents

i. Triphala

Bacteriocidal – Chlorhexidine

Bacteriostatic - MTAD

iii. Chelating agent

Mild pH – HEBP

Strong pH - EDTA

Sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) is the most widely used irrigant in endodontics. It has a broad history in the field of medicine and dentistry. During World War I, Henry Drysdale Dakin and Alexis Carrel have used the buffered 0.5% NaOCl solution to irrigate the infected wounds.3 It is bench mark in root canal irrigants because of the antibacterial and tissue-dissolving properties.2, 3 Nevertheless, the role of NaOCl as endodontic irrigant has been well-established long back but it is crucial to discuss the factors that has a role in the effectiveness of NaOCl. 2

Therefore, the aim of the present article is to discuss the advancement in sodium hypochlorite solution in relation to its concentration, irrigation techniques and factors affecting its efficacy and efficiency.

Mechanism of Action

Step 1: Hypochlorous acid, present in the sodium hypochlorite solution, when comes in contact with organic tissue, acts as a solvent and releases chlorine, which further combines with the protein amino group to form chloramines. 2, 3

Step 2: The chloramines inhibit cell metabolism. Chlorine has an antimicrobial action, preventing bacterial enzymes that results into an irreversible oxidation of sulphydryl group present in the bacteria. 2, 3

Step 3: Hypochlorous acid (HOCl-) and hypochlorite ions (OCl-) bring about amino acid degradation and hydrolysis. 2, 3

Pulpal remnants provide competent environment for the growth and propagation of microorganisms, hence the dissolution of pulpal remnant and organic tissue via sodium hypochlorite is inimitable in the success of endodontic treatment. 4, 5, 6

The organic component when comes in contact with the free chlorine molecules account for amino acid degradation and hydrolysis, and also saponification of fats. It is believed that the dissolution effect of sodium hypochlorite on necrotic tissue is more than that on normal, healthy tissue. 7

Consequential factors determining the strength of sodium hypochlorite are

  1. Exposure Time - Increase in exposure time would necessitate better antibacterial effectiveness. The suggested exposure time varies from 1 – 3 mins. 8

  2. Potency - Sodium hypochlorite incurs its antibacterial and tissue-dissolving ability due to the presence of free chlorine molecules, though as the interaction ensues between free chlorine molecules and organic tissue, the potency of solution decreases. Therefore, renewal of sodium hypochlorite solution is advised to enhance the potency of the solution by reimbursing the free chlorine molecules. 9

  3. Concentration – It is used at differed concentrations ranging between 0.5% - 6%. Its concentration is analogous to the rate of collagen dissolution and penetration depth.9, 10

  4. pH - The decrease in pH value leads to a higher proportion of HOCl, which is a strong antiseptic, resulting in greater antibacterial efficacy of the irrigant, while its tissue-dissolving capacity would be reduced. Neutralizing or stabilizing the pH value of NaOCl irrigant has been proposed as strategy of achieving ideal chemical properties. 8, 9, 10

Modus operandi for amelioration in chemical efficacy and potency of sodium hypochlorite

  1. Surfactant- High surface tension of sodium hypochlorite solution restricts its usefulness as an irrigant by decreasing its penetration into lateral canals and dentinal tubules. Thus, surfactants e.g. Benzalkonium chloride etc. were launched as supplement with NaOCl. It helps in strengthening the penetration depth along with the tissue dissolution capacity of sodium hypochlorite. 11, 12, 13, 14

  2. Constant Chelation - It is a prolific root canal irrigation practice where NaOCl is mixed with a chelating agent such as EDTA and HEDP. 11, 12, 13, 14 Sodium hypochlorite with HEDP - It is a weak chelating agent comparatively to EDTA but highly cooperative to sodium hypochlorite. Many authors have endorsed this combination as preferred choice than the NaOCl and EDTA method. This combination is found to be more potent as bactericidal and in dissolution of pulp. Nevertheless, there is no study that have suggested disparity in disposition of smear layer and dentinal debris. 15

  3. Increase temperature - The temperature of the solution can be raised via heating of the sodium hypochlorite solution in varied ways. This will ameliorate the efficiency and efficacy of sodium hypochlorite by accelerating the reaction. Heating of the solution can be achieved either by using preheated solution or heating it within the root canal by using agitation techniques such as sonic or ultrasonic devices. The rise in temperature also helps in improving the dissolution and antibacterial capabilities of the solution. 16

Diverse agitation approaches to expand the efficiency of sodium hypochlorite

Agitation is an arbitrating protocol that expand the efficiency and potency of sodium hypochlorite irrigating solution. Primarily it is suggested that the sonic activation is apparently less potent than that of ultrasonic activation because of its high-speed fluid flow. Additionally, size and taper of instrument, tip diameter, circumscription of the instrument within the reach of the canal and the type of irrigant, all do have a collective impact on the efficiency of the irrigating solution. 3, 17

  1. Sonic activation approach – EDDY, a sonically activated device armed by noncutting plastic tips that possibly diminish the risk of hampering the anatomy of root canal when comes in contact with them. 17 The device has a circular motion in over-all along with the added motion in the most apical part of the tip. 18

  2. EndoActivator (Ultrasonic activation approach) - It is ultrasonic activated device, encompassed of a handpiece along with wide-range sized polymer tips. The tip of this device stream dynamic intracanal fluid agitation by means of ultrasonic wave and high pressure and build up a swarm of dentinal debris. This physicochemical activation boosts the penetration, circulation and flow of sodium hypochlorite solution into the lateral or curved canals. 17, 18

  3. Vibringe – It is an innovative sonic irrigation approach that works in conjunction with perforated irrigation needle and sonic activation. It is battery enabled and produces vibrations when attached with the irrigating needle. It permits activation of the irrigation solution and high-pressure streaming at once within the root canal resulting in flushing out of dentinal debris. 18, 19, 20

  4. XP-endo Finisher – It is non tapered rotary tool, 25 nm in size made up of NiTi wire which enables it to have good handling and manipulation properties. It has dual shape feature which means a straight shape at room temperature while spoon-like shape at high temperature. This exclusive feature upsurges the probability to come into contact of canal walls and stir the irrigant once in motion. 3, 18

  5. Gentle Wave System – It is designed to work by applying negative pressure to flush out the debris during initial stages of biomechanical preparation because the tip is placed only in the pulp chamber. This approach helps to avoid sodium hypochlorite accident in the patient’s oral cavity. 17, 18

Shortcomings of sodium hypochlorite irrigant

  1. Hypochlorite accident – It is also acknowledged as apical extrusion occurs when sodium hypochlorite irrigant draw out beyond apex mostly seen in cases with open apex, root resorption, and malposition of irrigating needle. NaOCl is considered cytotoxic to periapical tissues so results into exuberant inflammatory response, discoloration and damage to localized tissue. 21, 22

  2. Cytotoxic – Sodium hypochlorite is a strong oxidizing agent which makes it cytotoxic to the periapical tissue and stem cells present in dentin. 23, 24, 25

  3. Post endo discomfort – The concentration of sodium hypochlorite plays an important role in the incidence rate of discomfort post biomechanical preparation. High concentration has high chances of cytotoxic effects on soft tissue which may last up to 24 hours. The intensity and duration of pain is directly proportional to the concentration of the irrigating solution. 26, 27, 28

  4. Catastrophic effect on dentin – This irrigant has a catastrophic effect on the mechanical properties of the dentin. It is in proportion to the concentration and frequency of the sodium hypochlorite irrigant resulting into the decrease in microhardness and modulus of elasticity of dentin by the development of a hydroxy appetite rich and collagen-scant dentin layer stated as Ghost layer. 29, 30

Conclusion

Sodium hypochlorite irrigant has a requisite part in the accomplishment of biomechanical preparation during root canal treatment. Numerous consequential factors such as the exposure time, potency, concentration, and pH of the sodium hypochlorite solution helps in determining its strength. There are many factors which ameliorate the chemical efficacy and potency of sodium hypochlorite such as surfactant e.g. Benzonium chloride, constant chelation by using EDTA and HEDP, and increase in temperature. The literature has suggested varied modes of agitation to increase the temperature likewise sonic and ultrasonic activation using EDDY, Endoactivator etc., vibringe, gentle wave system. Nonetheless, many studies are need to be done to establish the clinical efficacy and efficiency of these methods. In spite of numerous aids of sodium hypochlorite as an effective irrigant there are few limitations as well because of its cytotoxic nature and catastrophic effect on the mechanical properties of dentin which need to be taken care of.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

S Jaju P Jaju Newer root canal irrigants in horizon: a reviewInt J Dent2011185135910.1155/2011/851359

2 

C Cai X Chen Y Li Q Jiang Advances in the role of sodium hypochlorite irrigant in chemical preparation of root canal treatmentBiomed Res Int20231885828310.1155/2023/8858283

3 

D Kandaswamy N Venkateshbabu Root canal irrigantsJ Conserv Dent201013425664

4 

A Bystrom A Sundqvist Bacteriologic evaluation of the efficacy of mechanical root canal instrumentation in endodontic therapyScand J Dent Res19818943218

5 

M Zehnder Root canal irrigantsJ Endo200632538998

6 

MB Guneser D Arslan A Usumez Tissue dissolution ability of sodium hypochlorite activated by photoninitiated photoacoustic streaming techniqueJ Endod200541572932

7 

H Jungbluth M Marending G De-Deus B Sener M Zehnder Stabilizing sodium hypochlorite at high pH: effects on soft tissue and dentinJ Endo20113756936

8 

J Wang Y Jiang W Chen C Zhu J Liang Bacterial flora and extraradicular biofilm associated with the apical segment of teeth with post-treatment apical periodontitisJ Endo20123879549

9 

RM Clarkson AJ Moule H Podlich Dissolution of porcine incisor pulps in sodium hypochlorite solutions of varying compositions and concentrationsAust Dent J200651324551

10 

RG Macedo PR Wesselink F Zaccheo D Fanali LWM Van Der Sluis Reaction rate of NaOCl in contact with bovine dentine: effect of activation, exposure time, concentration and pHInt Endo J20104312110815

11 

L Giardino E Ambu C Becce L Rimondini M Morra Surface tension comparison of four common root canal irrigants and two new irrigants containing antibioticJ Endo2006321110913

12 

O Dragan I Tomuta D Casoni C Sarbu R Campian T Frentiu Influence of mixed additives on the physicochemical properties of a 5.25% sodium hypochlorite solution: an unsupervised multivariate statistical approachJ Endo20184422805

13 

F Bukiet G Couderc J Camps Wetting properties and critical micellar concentration of benzalkonium chloride mixed in sodium hypochloriteJ Endo2012381115259

14 

H Coaguila-Llerena I Barbieri M Tanomaru-Filho RT Leonardo AT Ramos G Faria Physicochemical properties, cytotoxicity and penetration into dentinal tubules of sodium hypochlorite with and without surfactantsRestor Dent Endod20204544710.5395/rde.2020.45.e47

15 

A Kfir C Goldenberg Hulsmann Z Metzger S Baxter Cleanliness and erosion of root canal walls after irrigation with a new HEDP-based solution vs. traditional sodium hypochlorite followed by EDTA. A scanning electron microscope studyClin Oral Investig202024103699706

16 

R Estevez AJ Conde O Valencia De Pablo F De La Torre G Rossi-Fedele R Cisneros Effect of passive ultrasonic activation on organic tissue dissolution from simulated grooves in root canals using sodium hypochlorite with or without surfactants and EDTAJ Endod201743711615

17 

W Hage RJG De Moor D Hajj G Sfeir DK Sarkis C Zogheib Impact of Different Irrigant Agitation Methods on Bacterial Elimination from Infected Root CanalsDent J2019736410.3390/dj7030064

18 

A Bystrom G Sundqvist Bacteriologic evaluation of the efficacy of mechanical root canal instrumentation in endodontic therapyScand J Dent Res19818943218

19 

KM Galler V Grubmuller R Schlichting M Widbiller A Eidt C Schuller Penetration depth of irrigants into root dentine after sonic, ultrasonic and photoacoustic activationInt Endod J201952812107

20 

S Liu H Zhai S Fu Evaluation of the cytotoxic effects of sodium hypochlorite on human dental stem cellsTropic J Pharma Res20191712237580

21 

RP Mitchell JC Baumgartner CM Sedgley Apical extrusion of sodium hypochlorite using different root canal irrigation systemsJ Endod20113712167781

22 

N V Ballal S Das Bss Rao M Zehnder D Mohn Chemical, cytotoxic and genotoxic analysis of etidronate in sodium hypochlorite solutionInt Endod J2019528122834

23 

BML Nogueira TIC Pereira VF Pedrinha PA Rodrigues Effects of different irrigation solutions and protocols on mineral content and ultrastructure of root canal dentineIran Endod J201813220915

24 

D Elumalai A Kumar R K Tewari S K Mishra Newer Endodontic irrigation devices: An updateIOSR J Dent Med Sci201413648

25 

JG Roeland Maarten De Moor Meire Efficacy of Ultrasonic versus Laser-activated Irrigation to Remove Artificially Placed Dentin Debris PlugsJ Endod201036915803

26 

JF Siqueira IN Rocas SR Santos KC Lima FA Magalhaes M De Uzeda Efficacy of instrumentation techniques and irrigation regimens in reducing the bacterial population within root canalsJ Endod20022831814

27 

D Pouch W Bohne B Enkel Comparative Safety of Various Intracanal Irrigation SystemsJ Endod20073545459

28 

JL Hockett Antimicrobial efficacy of two irrigation techniques in tapered and nontapered canal preparations: an in vitro studyJ Endod2008341113747

29 

LI Grossman Origin of microorganisms in traumatized, pulpless, sound teethJ Dent Res1967465513

30 

A Bystrom G Sundqvist Bacteriologic evaluation of the efficacy of mechanical root canal instrumentation in endodontic therapyScand J Dent Res19818943218



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 15-03-2024

Accepted : 05-04-2024


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.idjsr.2024.013


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 401

PDF Downloaded: 106



Medical Abbreviation List